I never knew I could be more addicted to a show like Schmigadoon. I was able to watch it when we were paying for the Apple TV+ add on on Amazon Prime. We were paying for it because we were watching Ted Lasso and cancelled the subscription once we finished watching it. It has been renewed for a fourth season so we may have to pay for it again. However, I was able to binge watch the entire series before the cancellation fully came through. Let me tell you, I have a lot to say about it.
Before I start the review, I must tell you what it is about. It tells the story of a couple, both doctors, named Josh (played by Keegan Michael-Key) and Melissa (played by Cecily Strong) that go on a couple's retreat because their relationship is falling apart. The first season is set in the town of Schmigadoon (a play on Brigadoon), which blends elements of various Golden Age musicals of the 1940s and 1950s. However, the second season relocates the action to the city of Schmicago (a play on Chicago) and incorporates the darker, edgier themes of 1960s and 1970s musicals. In my personal opinion, season 1 is far better than season 2. This is because the plot, characters and the soundtrack were better developed and more iconic. The jokes as well were more funny because they would sometimes reference the fact that women essentially had very little civil rights back then and that the female characters in the musicals were according to Melissa "not fully developed" because times have changed and that women have more rights than ever before. Unfortunately, the show was cancelled after those two seasons. It turns out that season three would have been titled Into the Schmoods, a play on Into the Woods, and would have parodied that musical as well as Cats, Les Miserables, The Phantom of the Opera and other stage and film musicals of the 1980s and 1990s. I don't think it would have worked and not as good as the previous two seasons. I feel like the ending of season was perfect. I'm not going to spoil anything. However, there is a recently adapted stage show and it adapts the first season only and that Cinco Paul, the creator and songwriter of the show, is hoping to adapt all three seasons (yes, including the third season that didn't happen).
Key and Strong lead a interstellar cast including Dove Cameron, Kristin Chenoweth, Alan Cumming, Ariana DeBose and Aaron Tveit. Some of the cast actually returned to star in season 2 playing completely different roles than season 1, which really made me happy and amused because I really enjoyed everybody's performances as they were all able to play very different characters effectively. What I found very surprising was Dove Cameron's singing voice. I was fully aware that she has a music career and starred in the Descendants film series (with Chenoweth playing her mother). I have never seen Descendants and the only song that I have heard is Boyfriend and she sounds completely different in that song than what she sounded like in this. I think she sounds so much better in this because she is showing off her musical theatre talents and not gonna lie, she should be in more musical theatre stuff on stage.
Danny Bailey. Let's talk about him. For context, Danny Bailey is a character in season 1 and he is played by Aaron Tveit. He is the so called "rapscallion" of the town and he works as the carnival barker. For those who don't know what a carnival barker is, it is a person who loudly promotes and attempts to attract customers to a carnival or other entertainment event. The character is based on Billy Bigelow from Rodgers and Hammerstein's musical Carousel. He is by far my all time favourite character in the ENTIRE show. I always like to watch an absolute dream boat in a film or TV show (because, you know, they are the best part of the whole thing) and Danny Bailey is one of them, He can sing, he can dance, he can do the whole lot. He can convince me to come to the carnival (and to his bedroom I know that for sure *wink* *wink*). The moment he started singing You Can't Tame Me was the moment I realised that I was going to have this strange crush on him. Aaron Tveit did a really good job at playing a charismatic, proudly single man who dresses fabulously. He really suits a turtle neck and high-waist trousers. He needs to wear them more often.
The overall vibe of the show is just so vibrant and positive throughout. Despite season 2's whole aesthetic is meant to be more gritty, dark and negative overall, it still has the positivity and excellent soundtrack that season 1 had. The costumes for both seasons are very colourful and obviously very fitting for the time period it is meant to fit (1940-1950s musicals being set in Civil War/1900s time and 1960s/1970s musicals set mainly 1920s to parody Chicago with a sprinkle of 1960s with the hippy scenes). The soundtrack and characters was actually meant to parody, or should I say sample, actually characters and songs from the musicals they were meant to parody. These unfortunately lowers my rating because I am not a musical nerd, but I do enjoy some musicals, and I didn't get most of the references. I got some of them, but not all of them. However, the soundtrack and characters receive all of the positive feedback from me. If I had the opportunity to binge watch the show again, I would definitely take the opportunity.
7/10